ProgramMaster Logo
Conference Tools for 2020 AWS Professional Program
Register as a New User
Submit An Abstract
Propose A Symposium
Presenter/Author Tools
Organizer/Editor Tools
About this Abstract
Meeting 2020 AWS Professional Program
Symposium 2020 AWS Professional Program
Presentation Title The Correlation of Hardness to Toughness and the Superior Low Temperature Impact Properties of Martensite in RPV Steels Applied to Temper Bead Qualification
Author(s) Boeing Jorgensen Smith, Antonio Ramirez, Steven McCracken, Stephen Tate
On-Site Speaker (Planned) Boeing Jorgensen Smith
Abstract Scope Introduction: Temper bead welding is often used as an alternative to PWHT when welding hardenable steels in the fabrication and repair process, commonly employed in the nuclear industry. Historically, qualification of TB welding techniques have employed Charpy V-notch testing to ensure acceptable HAZ fracture toughness; however, ASME Section IX (QW-290) included a provision, in 2004, that allows temper bead qualification through tensile, bend, and peak hardness without impact testing requirements. Previous work shows that for SA-508, a common pressure vessel alloy, tempered Martensite has the highest toughness of the microstructures present in the heat affected zone. This work looks to find a quantitative correlation between instrumented indentation, the newly found Hardness Drop Parameter, and critical brittle volume fraction with impact toughness. These correlations will be the foundation for creating recommendations for the current TB qualification criterion from just hardness indents but based on impact toughness properties, which supports the formation of tougher Martensitic microstructures for pressure vessel steels, specifically A508 and A387. Experimental Methodology: This work utilized a GleebleŽ 3800 Thermo-Mechanical Simulator to create two different sets of HAZ samples, round and square, on four different materials. Two different heats of A508 and A387 were simulated at different cooling rates ranging from 0.25⁰C/s to 55⁰C/s after a 969°C austenization for five minutes to form a homogeneous grain size. The samples were then tempered for one second at different temperatures to create different levels of tempering. Square samples were cut down and the impact tested in accordance with ASTM E23. Fractography data was then collected for the broken samples using an SEM. Extensive hardness testing, instrumented indentation, and quantitative metallography was then conducted on the set of round simulated samples. A phase fraction analysis for each untempered cooling rate was then performed using Nital etching and quantitative metallography. Electron microprobe carbon analysis and high-resolution SEM imaging was also performed to show the contrast in carbon partitioning and autotempering upon cooling respectively. Results and Discussion: Instrumented Indentation will give localized toughness data to give information on where the most brittle point of the HAZ in TB welds occur in order to streamline qualification. The hardness drop will give a quantitative estimate for impact toughness from just a hardness indent during qualification (Hardness Drop Parameter). Lastly if a brittle zone is detected based on the Hardness Drop Parameter, the critical brittle volume fraction will give insight on how many brittle zones can be present before it becomes detrimental to the mechanical properties of the part. These three correlations will provide data to support an alternative TB qualification criterion which would shift current practices that produce brittle Bainitic microstructures to producing tougher Martensitic microstructures. The idea of shifting these practices toward producing more Martensitic microstructures to improve impact toughness is a paradox when thinking in general about steel metallurgy. However, during this study it was found that the untempered Martensite exhibited high impact toughness at low temperatures. A fundamental dive on why this untempered Martensite had superior mechanical properties was taken and produced two other questions, is grain size refinement beneficial from introducing other phases into a Martensitic matrix and is Martensite being autotempered upon cooling. A common way of increasing toughness is through effective grain size refinement. A common way to perform this grain size refinement is by introducing multiple phases into the microstructural matrix. This has commonly been done to reduce or even in some cases attempt to eliminate Martensite in some pressure vessel steels microstructures. This leaves a small fraction of Martensite which is the final microstructure formed from austenite based on CCT diagrams. This allows for a significant amount of carbon to partition to the austenite, which is later transformed to the Martensite during the formation of the predominate microstructural constituent, in this case Bainite. This Martensite then has elevated carbon content which will significantly lower its impact properties. Secondly during the Martensite formation in some common pressure vessel steels, A387 and A508, Martensite is autotempered upon cooling due to the high Martensite start and finish temperatures at 400⁰C and 300⁰C respectively. Conclusions: This will give industry partners a specific TB microhardness qualification criterion. This criterion will clearly outline the specific hardness testing load and spacing parameters making it safer, simpler, and cheaper to implement during qualification than current practices. This criterion will also shift current welding practices toward producing tougher Martensitic microstructures as opposed to more brittle Bainitic microstructures in the nuclear industry. Based on this research, untempered Martensite is not detrimental for mechanical properties, specifically impact toughness in structural steels. This is because low carbon Lath Martensite has very good impact properties, grain refinement normally has detrimental tradeoffs like introducing a brittle phase into the matrix and carbon partitioning, and untempered Martensite in modern structural steels is autotempered upon cooling due to the high MF temperature around 300⁰C. This will further the field’s fundamental knowledge on the low temperature impact properties of Martensite in pressure vessel steels. Keywords: Martensite, CVN, impact properties, HV, Hardness, Temper Bead Welding, autotempering, carbon portioning.
Proceedings Inclusion? Definite: Other (describe below)


101st Year of the American Welding Society: Changes in Welding & Outlook
Additive Manufacture of the First Concentric Reduction Sleeve Used in the Brazilian Oil and Gas Industry
Additive Manufacturing Using Semi-Solids
Advances in Robotic Arc DED AM for Shipbuilding
An Efficient Part-Scale Model to Predict Distortion on Overhang Structure in Laser Powder Bed Fusion Additive Manufacturing
An Overview of LME Cracking in Advanced High Strength Automotive Steels
Analysis and Control of Humping Defect in Laser Wire Direct Deposition Process
Analysis of Dynamic Evolution of Weld Pool for the Real-Time Monitoring of Penetration Using Deep Learning
Avoiding Tool Failure and Defects in Friction Stir Welding Using Machine Learning
Bondline Properties in High Frequency Welding of Steels
Building a Digital Twin for Welding Process Monitoring, Visualization and Control Based on Deep Learning
Characterization of the Fourth Generation of Nickel-Chromium Welding Products for Nuclear Service
Chipping Study of Friction Element Welding
Computational Modeling on Defect Formation during Self-Reacting Friction Stir Welding
Copper Foil Welding for Battery Manufacturing
Correlating Laser Power and Microstructural Properties of Additively Manufactured Ti-6Al-4V Fabricated by Directed Energy Deposition
Creep Strength Variation in Simulated ICHAZs of Grade 91 Steel
Design of an Austenitic Steel Weldment System Using ICME
Development of Industry 4.0 Software for Arc-Welding Energy Monitoring and Traceability
Development of Interlayer Technology to Join Advanced Materials for the Transportation Industry
Development, Optimization, and Mechanical Testing of ER80S-G Girth Welds on Internally Clad API 5L Grade X65 Pipes
Dissimilar Joining of Carbon Fiber Reinforced Composite to Magnesium Alloy by Friction Self-Piercing Riveting Process
Effect of Aluminum on Primary Carbides in Chromium Carbide Overlays
Effect of Chemical Composition of Welding Consumable on Slag Formation and Weld Corrosion Resistance
Effect of Heating Rate on Austenite Formation in a Low Carbon Microalloyed Steel
Effect of Phase Transformations on Mechanical Properties of Ti Free Grade 300 Maraging Steel Manufactured by Laser Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF)
Electron Beam Brazing of Stainless Steel using NIORO Filler Metal
Evaluation of Braze Joints for Hydrogen Purification Diffuser
Experimental Studies of Wire Feeding Electron Beam Welding-Brazing of Aluminum to Stainless Steel and Titanium
Failure Analysis: Evaluating a Low Strength Solder Joint
Fundamentals and Techniques for High-Speed Imaging of Welding
GMA Weldability Between AISI 316L Pipes Manufactured by Conventional and Additive Manufacturing Processes
High Deposition Gas Metal Arc Variants for Directed Energy Deposition Additive Manufacturing
High Efficient Modification of Arc Welding Processes via Modeling and Sensing Weld Pool Behaviors
High Penetration Buried Arc Gas Metal Arc Welding for Shipyard Steel Plate Fabrication
Hybrid Laser Welding on API 5L Pipeline Steels
Hyper-Duplex Stainless Steel Intermetallic Precipitation Behavior during Cladding
Improper Weld Field Fabrication Caused Premature Failure
In-situ Measurement and Numerical Simulation for Linear Friction Welding of Complex Titanium Structures
In-situ Synchrotron Diffraction Measurement of Solidification Behavior during Laser Welding of Multi-Principal-Component Alloy
Induction Heating-Assisted Friction Stir Welding in Low Carbon Steel Plates
Influence of Composition on the Solidification and Mechanical Properties of HP-Modified Heat-Resistant Austenitic Stainless Steels
Influence of Cooling Rate on Microstructure Formation in Rapid Solidification of Ni2MnGa Alloy
Influence of Hydrogen on the Softened HAZ in Various Carbon Steel Welds
Integrated Computational Materials Engineering (ICME) Techniques to Enable a Material-Informed Digital Twin Prototype for Marine Structures
Integrated Modeling of Multi-Process Automotive Lap Joining – Part 3: Microstructure and Mechanical Properties
Investigation of a Curly Toolpath in Friction Stir Welding
Investigation of Laves Phase Formation in Inconel 718 Fabricated by Laser Powder Bed Fusion
Investigation of Thermally Assisted Friction Element Welding
Joining Dissimilar Metals of DP590 Steel and AZ31B Magnesium Sheets by Ultrasonic Spot Welding
Low-cycle Fatigue Evaluations of Ni-Steel Dissimilar Joints for Coke Drum Welding Repairs
Machine Learning for Automatic Recognition of Microstructures
Material Characteristics of Wire Arc Additive Manufactured Inconel 718
Mechanical Properties Assessment of Carbon and Low-Alloy Steel Parts Built by GMA-DED
Mechanics of the Solid-State Bonding and Prediction of Thermomechanical Responses in Friction Stir Welding
Mechanistic Models and Machine Learning to Mitigate Common Defects in Metal Printing
Metallic Powder Core Tubular Wire Development for Additive Manufacturing
Microstructural and Mechanical Property Characterization of Reaction Synthesis Aluminum Metal Matrix Composites Produced by Additive Manufacturing
Microstructural Characterization and Mechanical Property Evaluation of Fusion Zones in a 10 wt% Ni Steel Weld Metal
Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of 410 Stainless Steel Using Different Shielding Gases in the Wire-Arc Additive Process
Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Intercritical-Treated Grade 91 Steel
Microstructures and Microhardness of LENS DED Deposits of Ti/TiC MMCs
Mitigation of Liquid Metal Embrittlement in Galvannealed AHSS Welds Using High Entropy Alloy Filler
Modal Analysis of Ultrasonic Welding to Enable Multi-Spot Dissimilar Material Joining
Modeling and Comparing Human Welder’s Operation Between Stereo Camera and Virtual Reality
Modeling of In-Situ Tempering of a Creep Resistant Ferritic Martensitic Steel during Multi-Layer Additive Manufacturing
Modeling of Mash Seam Welding Using Improved Electro-Thermo-Mechanical Simulation
Modelling of Laser Cladding Using Gaussian Heat Source Profile and Verification with Experimental Results
Multi-Scale and Multi-Physics Modeling of Process-Microstructure-Property Relationship in Metal Additive Manufacturing
New Approaches in Friction Welding Advanced PM Nickel Base Superalloys
Novel Thermal Spray Alloy for Corrosive Applications
Numerical Study on Heat Transfer Mechanisms in Electric Arc Columns
Optimization of Tool Path and Microstructure in Large Scale Metal Additive Manufacturing with Multi-Heat Sources
Phase Transformation Analysis and Microstructural Characterization of the Heat Affected Zone in Grade 92 Steel Welds
Procedure Qualification Schemes and Build Results for Directed Energy Deposition Additive Manufacturing
Process Control Using Predictive Equations for Zero Programming Laser Cladding Facility
Process, Microstructure and Fracture Mode of Magnesium to Steel Dissimilar Metal Spot Joints
Pulsed-Arc Welding of Battery Tabs for Vehicle Electrification
PWHT of 347SS Weldments for Thermal Energy Storage Concentrating Solar Power Applications
Real-Time Prediction of Weld Penetration from Dynamic Weld Pool-Arc Images Deep Learning Based
Recent Developments in Metal Additive Manufacturing
Research and Development of a Novel TIG Welding Technology for Joining Thin Sheets Applying in Metal Forming Field
Residual Stress Measurement on High-Strength Steel Panels for Shipbuilding Application
Resistance Spot Welding Challenges, Root Causes, and Suggested Welding Practices When Welding 3rd Generation AHSS
Role of Retained Austenite in Mechanical Response of Additively Manufactured 17-4 PH Stainless Steel
Simulation of Laser Brazing of Sheet Panels and Parametric Studies on Thermally-Induced Distortion Reduction
SMART Camera in the Welding Torch for Manual Welding Quality and Productivity
State-of-the-Art of Underwater Wet Welding Practice
Strain Ageing of Inconel 740H and 347H
Suitability of Using Thin Wire in Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing (GMA-DED)
Sulfur Implantation in Alloy 690 for the Study of Ductility-Dip Cracking
Surface Modification via Metal Deposition and Selective Alteration
Surface Treatment of 3-D Printing Parts
Temper Bead Welding
The Correlation of Hardness to Toughness and the Superior Low Temperature Impact Properties of Martensite in RPV Steels Applied to Temper Bead Qualification
The Role of Inclusions in Duplex Stainless Steels Produced Using Laser-Based Directed Energy Deposition Additive Manufacturing
Ultrasonic Vibration Assisted Electron Beam Additive Manufacturing
Unit Block-Based Process Planning Strategy of WAAM for Complex Shell-Shaped Component
Universal Representation of Arc Shape and Arc Column Characteristics for DC Electric Arcs Burning in Argon and Helium
Variation in Microstructure and Properties in the Heat Affected and Fusion Zones of Low-Density Fe-Mn-Al-C Steel Welds
Variations in Microstructure and Mechanical Properties with Solidification Mode in L-PBF 316L
Weld Metal Cooling Rate-Mechanical Property Response of Fe-10Ni Steel Gas Metal Arc Weld Deposits and Other Experimental Observations
Weldability and Microstructural Evolution of Fusion Welds in a γ’ Strengthened TRIP Steel
Welding and Joining Challenges in the Astrospace Industry
Welding of FeMnAl High-Manganese Lightweight Steel
Wetting and Low Temperature Bonding of Zirconia Metallized with Ti-Containing Active Solders

Questions about ProgramMaster? Contact