ProgramMaster Logo
Conference Tools for 2022 AWS Professional Program
Register as a New User
Submit An Abstract
Propose A Symposium
Presenter/Author Tools
Organizer/Editor Tools
About this Abstract
Meeting 2022 AWS Professional Program
Symposium 2022 AWS Professional Program
Presentation Title Meta-Analysis of Fatigue Properties in Additively Manufactured 316L Austenitic Stainless Steel
Author(s) Ian J. Wietecha-Reiman, Stephen Sabol, David Driggers, Todd A. Palmer
On-Site Speaker (Planned) Ian J. Wietecha-Reiman
Abstract Scope Introduction: Fatigue behavior in additively manufactured (AM) 316L austenitic stainless steel is influenced by variations in material properties, processing routes, and testing procedures. Sensitivity to even slight variations in these conditions negatively impacts any direct and simple comparison between individual data sets and precludes the ability to identify larger trends in fatigue behavior and performance. The complicated solidification and thermal history AM alloys experience makes it more important to be able to leverage larger bodies of available data to understand how processing defects and unique microstructures are influencing fatigue behavior. The large number of factors contributing to the variability in the available fatigue data for AM processed 316L austenitic stainless steel coupled with the small sample sizes of each data set limits broader insight into how fatigue properties are impacted by the AM process. By aggregating available smaller data sets and developing protocols for data categorization and standardization, statistical techniques can be used to discern the nuanced and varied behavior of fatigue in AM 316L. Experimental Procedure: Fatigue data from literature was compiled encompassing both wrought and laser-powder bed fusion (L-PBF) processed 316L austenitic stainless steel. Data were standardized to equivalent fully-reversed axial stress amplitudes by accounting for changes in load ratio and loading configuration, thus reducing the dimensionality of the obtained data set. Commonly reported variables pertaining to mechanical properties, processing conditions, and surface conditions were categorized. The objectives of the statistical meta-analysis were to describe the general scatter of fatigue behavior, quantify contributions to varied fatigue life, and to discern between defect and microstructure driven behavior from the fatigue response, or S-N curve. All statistical analyses were performed using the R programming language. General scatter was determined for data subsetted by each categorized variable. Simple linear regression models provide coefficients of determination and mean fatigue lives. Contributions to fatigue life were then quantified using an analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) model with an additional blocking factor to improve model precision. An iterative process of model formulation, variable selection, and validity checking was performed to obtain a statistically and practically sufficient model. Each compiled S-N curve dataset was then regressed using Basquin’s equation to obtain the fatigue response. After performing a similar procedure to identify contributions to fatigue response in an ANCOVA model, fatigue responses were clustered using hierarchical and k-means clustering techniques to determine which groups of material exhibited similar behavior. Results from the meta-analysis were extended to runout and strain-controlled fatigue data. Fatigue behavior groups in runout were compared using a Weibull analysis with a Kolmogorov-Smirnov test to test group membership. A set of specimens were produced and tested under strain-controlled fatigue for comparison to compiled data. Specimens were hot-isostatic pressed (HIP) to mitigate defect effects. Testing was conducted at strain amplitudes greater than 0.002 mm/mm. Results and Discussion: Linear models and data handling practices were effective in capturing scatter and contributions to both fatigue life and response in AM processed 316L fatigue. Load ratio and loading method could be effectively standardized to remove their main effects from models for fatigue life. Models for general scatter and fatigue life were able to quantify and verify several of the commonly relied upon relationships that tend to be used qualitatively. Impacts of surface machining, application of stress relief, annealing, or HIP treatments, and build angle were obtained. Analysis of fatigue responses, in addition to quantifying contributions to changes in S-N curve slope, was able to discern two statistically and practically distinct groups of fatigue behavior. By considering the categorized variables and parallels between grouped datasets, these two groups in AM 316L could broadly be attributed to defect driven and microstructure driven failure. Conditions where the presence of processing defects or their coupling with the applied stresses diminished favor the microstructure driven failure group. HIP treatment, machining, and choosing more favorable orientations with processing defects favor microstructure driven fatigue. While standardization removed the main effects of load ratio and loading method for fatigue life, their impact was still observed for fatigue response. More severe loading conditions favored defect driven fatigue. Extending these results to strain-controlled and runout data demonstrated a general dichotomy between defect and microstructure driven fatigue. HIP strain-controlled fatigue data obtained for this study exhibited nearly wrought behavior albeit a decreased fatigue strength in contrast to the stark deviation of defect driven material in both the low-cycle and very-high cycle fatigue regimes. Weibull analysis of runout data confirmed that the two fatigue behavior comes from different statistical distributions with carry over to the very-high cycle fatigue regime. Conclusion: Published fatigue data with varied testing conditions can be effectively compiled and analyzed using statistical and meta-analytic techniques in a way extensible to multiple regimes of fatigue failure and new datasets. Protocols for this type of meta-analysis were developed and able to provide quantitative insight to both commonly observed qualitative knowledge and reveal new insights regarding the fatigue behavior of AM 316L. In particular, analysis of the fatigue response broadly showed defect driven and microstructure driven fatigue behavior in AM 316L. This dichotomy may be related back to the assessed categorized variables and how they act to either mitigate the presence of processing defects or diminish their interaction with imposed stresses.
Proceedings Inclusion? Undecided


2020 Thomas Medal Presentation: Keeping Pace with Change
Addressing Materials Challenges and Other Barriers to the Future of Additive Manufacturing
An AI-based Vision Methodology for Self-guided Seam Tracking in Gas Metal Arc Welding
An Investigation into the Effects of Stir Zone Chemistry on Fracture Toughness in Friction Stir Welded Pipeline Grade Steel
Analysis of Temperature and Velocity Fields in the GTAW Arc for Argon
Application of Polarity Switching Capacitor Discharge Welding to Aluminum Sheet Structures
Buried Arc GMAW for Single Pass Single Sided Erection Joints onboard Ships
Carbonitride Development and Heat Treatment Response of Additively Manufactured 17-4 PH Stainless Steel with Variations in Composition
Characterization of Dissimilar Materials 410 Martensite Stainless Steel and Mild Steel Component Produced by Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing
Deleterious Phase Avoidance in Additively Manufactured Functional Gradients through Path Planning
Developing an Automated Defect Detection TIG Welding Robot with a future Adaptive Implementation
Development of a Temperature-Dependent Material Property Database for DH36 Steel
Droplet Temperature in GMAW
Effect of Composition on Solidification Behavior and Resultant Microstructure in Dissimilar Electron Beam Welds between Commercially Pure Iron and Nickel
Energy Balance in Gas Metal Arc Welding
Evaluating the Carbide Precipitation Behavior During Short Term Tempering and its Influence on Impact Toughness.
Evaluation of Spatter Production with Deep Learning Algorithms
Evolution of Analytical Modelling Approaches for Resistance Spot Welding: A Historical Perspective
Fatigue Properties of Dissimilar Aluminum to Steel Welds Joined by Ultrasonic Interlayered Resistance Spot Welding Process
Hardness Prediction by Incorporating Heat Transfer and Molten Pool Fluid Flow in a Multi-pass, Multi-layer Weld for Onsite Repair of CSEF Grade 91 Steel
High Speed Video (HSV) and Synchronized Data Acquisition (DAQ) to Observe Welding Process Stability
How to Accurately Monitor the Weld Penetration from Dynamic Weld Pool Serial Images using CNN-LSTM Deep Learning Model?
Hybrid Manufacturing: Combining Additive Friction Stir Deposition, Metrology, and Machining
IIW Commission I Activities on Additive Manufacturing
Impact of Beam Deflection on Porosity during Keyhole Mode Laser Welding of Aluminum Alloys
In-situ Liquid Nitrogen Cryogenic Cooling for Interpass Control in High-Duty Cycle Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing of Large Components for Navy Applications
Influence of Microstructure on the Mechanism of Hydrogen-assisted Cracking in Dissimilar Metal Welds for Refinery Application
Integrated Modeling of Defect Formation during Deep Penetration Laser Welding of Creep Resistant Nickel Base Alloys
Investigation of Fe-10 wt.% Ni Steel Weld Metal Hydrogen Induced Cracking Susceptibility using the Gapped Bead on Plate (GBOP) Test
Large-Scale Hybrid Manufacturing using Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing
Machine Learning-based Process Characterization and Efficient Adaptive Control in Robotic Arc Welding
Material Characterization of Grade 91 Steel Welds using Micro-resolution Ultrasonic Imaging System.
Mechanical Design and Development of a Five Degree-of-Freedom TIG Welding Robot
Meta-Analysis of Fatigue Properties in Additively Manufactured 316L Austenitic Stainless Steel
Micro Cross Weld Tensile Testing of Dissimilar Metal Welds using Digital Image Correlation
Micro GTAW Applied to a Battery Pack for Racing Applications
Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Electron Beam Additively Manufactured Ti-6Al-4V
Optimizing Productivity of Hyper Duplex Stainless Steels Overlay while Avoiding Sigma Phase Formation
Phase Transformation Behavior of Fe-10wt.% Ni Steel Weld Metal
Predicting Operation Windows for High-Frequency Induction Aluminum Tube Welding through Machine Learning
Process-Feature-Microstructure-Property Relationships for A9628 Directed Energy Deposition Additive Manufactured Steel Components
Real-Time Recognition of Arc Weld Pool Using Image Segmentation Network
Role of Standards in Welding Safety
Scaling Analysis of Thermal and Mechanical Process in Friction Stir Welding
The Effects of Post-Weld Processing on Friction Stir Welded Additive Manufactured AlSi10Mg
The Influence of Boride Phase Transformations on Heat-Affected Zone Liquation Cracking Susceptibility in Laser Welded 304L Stainless Steel
The Influence of Dynamic Behaviors Characteristics of Molten Pool on the Weld Formation during the High Speed Laser Welding
The International Institute of Welding: Strategic Directions for Welding and Joining Research and Industrial Applications
Use of Low Transition Temperature Steel Alloys In Welded Overlays for High Wear Applications
Welding Investigation of Wrought FeMnAl Steel
WeldVac – A Quiet, Clean Metal Removal System

Questions about ProgramMaster? Contact